Brand vs. Manufacturers vs. Distributors

Education and Awareness

Brand vs. Manufacturers vs. Distributors

Understand liability across brands, manufacturers, and distributors.

By 24 Jul 20265 min read

As the EU cracks down on greenwashing, one question keeps coming up across fashion supply chains: who is actually liable when a sustainability claim fails verification? The brand? The manufacturer? The distributor? The short answer is it depends, but brands usually carry the greatest risk. The longer answer is nuanced, and understanding it is critical for anyone operating in the EU fashion market. Here’s how liability typically breaks down under EU sustainability and consumer protection frameworks, and what each brand should be doing to protect itself. 

EU sustainability regulation is built on a simple idea: whoever makes the environmental claim is responsible for proving it. Liability is not assigned based on who caused the impact, but on who communicates the claim to the market. This means the same product can expose different teams to risk depending on who markets it, who labels it, and who sells it under their name. Let’s break this down by role. 

The brand is the primary risk holder. Why? Brands control marketing and messaging. They decide which sustainability claims appear on products, websites, and campaigns. This causes them to be the most exposed and risk their own name and reputation. If a brand uses sustainability buzzwords such as “lower impact” or "eco-friendly", they must be able to substantiate that claim, even if the underlying data comes from suppliers. So what are brands liable for when making claims? Accuracy is a huge factor and must be checked across all channels (B2B, B2C, online, offline). “Our supplier told us” is not a legal defense in the EU. Also, any use of icons, labels, and visuals implying environmental benefit. Basically, any claim that is not verified before publication, brands are liable for. 

Manufacturers usually don’t make consumer-facing claims, but that doesn’t mean they’re risk-free. They must have accurate data and declarations that they can provide to the brands. This cannot include any misrepresentation of materials, processes, or certifications. If a manufacturer falsely claims that a fabric is recycled or a process is low-impact, they may face contractual liability, and in some cases, regulatory consequences. Specifically, whether misinformation is intentional or systematic. However, EU regulators usually pursue the claim maker first, not the upstream producer.

Distributors, agents, and retailers often assume they’re “just selling” products, but that’s not always safe to assume. They can become liable if they add or reframe claims in product descriptions. Most distributors will do this if they are trying to sell a sustainability collection and use sustainability filters to get the product off the shelf. In these cases, the distributor is no longer a neutral intermediary; they are actively communicating an environmental claim. This is extremely risky since retailers using sustainability icons without verification may be held responsible alongside the brand. 


So what happens when multiple parties are exposed? In complex supply chains, liability can overlap. Some examples may be a brand markets a “sustainable” product, the manufacturer provides inaccurate data, and the retailer amplifies the claim. Regulators may still focus on the brand, but commercial disputes and reputational damages often spread across all parties. This is why contracts, documentation, and internal controls matter more than ever. 

Across roles, EU authorities focus on a plethora of factors; however, there are key points that stand out. For example, who made the claim public, whether the claim was substantiated before use, if verification is independent and credible, and whether consumers or B2B partners were misled. Any of these causes may be flagged; the important thing to remember is that intent matters less than impact and evidence. 

We’ve discussed all the risks and liabilities that come with failing claim verification. However, how can companies reduce risk? For brands, focusing on treating sustainability claims as legal statements is a great start. By verifying claims before publication and maintaining documentation, it is quite simple to make truthful statements. Manufacturers need to provide accurate data that does not overstate any sustainability performance. Clearly defining assumptions and limitations reduces any chance that data can be misinterpreted, leading to less risk of verification failure. Lastly, distributors must fact-check any claims presented to them to avoid repeating unverified claims. Being cautious with sustainability labels and filters on merchandising will align internal merchandising and compliance. 

EU sustainability verification is shifting accountability downstream toward whoever speaks the loudest. In practice, brands usually carry the heaviest burden. The other teams still play a role, with manufacturers supporting verification with data and distributors becoming liable when they add their own sustainability spin. The era of shared assumptions is over. The era of documented responsibility has begun. 

In the EU, liability doesn’t stop at the factory gate; it follows the claim. If you say it, you must prove it. If you repeat it, you must trust it. If you sell it, you may share the risk. For fashion brands and their partners, understanding this division of responsibility isn’t optional; it’s fundamental to operating safely in the EU market. 

‹ Back to the journal

Keep reading

Stories that lead
back to better brands